Browsed by
Category: Publication

Perception of Physical Activity Leaderboards

Perception of Physical Activity Leaderboards

Digital health tools to promote physical activity frequently incorporate leaderboards, to encourage physical activity by activating social comparison processes (self-evaluation relative to others). However, the acceptability and utility of leaderboards to the general population remain unclear.

Dr. Kayla Nuss, Klein Buendel Scientist, collaborated on a set of research studies led by Rowan University to compare leaderboard display formats and their relationship to physical activity motivation. The significance, methods, analysis, and findings of the two studies are detailed in the journal Digital Health.

One hundred forty-five (145) young adults from the United States (Study 1) and 1,510 adults from Germany and Austria (Study 2) evaluated two common leaderboard display formats and provided explanations for preferences. Participants also reported their physical activity motivation following exposure to fixed (Study 1) or randomized (Study 2) leaderboard placements. Open-ended responses were analyzed using content analysis and sentiment analysis in Python.

Familiarity with leaderboards was low (Study 1: 43%; Study 2: 19%) and display preferences varied. Approximately 43-49% across both studies reported high physical activity motivation post-leaderboard exposure. Both analytic methods showed that these participants subsequently expressed a range of perceptions of physical activity leaderboards (positive, negative, and neutral). Further, ∼21% of each sample reported low motivation for physical activity after exposure, yet their perceptions ranged from rejecting competitive comparisons to recognizing that leaderboards could benefit others. Sentiment analysis further revealed that participants who reported no display preference expressed the most negative sentiment, regardless of their motivation.

Findings demonstrate considerable heterogeneity in adults’ perceptions of physical activity leaderboards, even among those who experience high motivation for physical activity following leaderboard exposure. Because a single ideal format may not meet all users’ needs, personalized designs that account for individual factors may better support long-term engagement with digital health tools and sustained physical activity.

This research was supported by an NIH Director’s New Innovator Award (HL173857; Dr. Danielle Arigo, Principal Investigator) and Klein Buendel. Collaborators include Ninelle Edenne, Raj Harsora, Angelica Rivera, and Dr. Danielle Arigo from Rowan University; Dr. Laura Konig from the University of Vienna; and Dr. Kayla Nuss from Klein Buendel.

Body Neutrality Workbook to Increase Physical Activity

Body Neutrality Workbook to Increase Physical Activity

Dr. Kayla Nuss, Klein Buendel Scientist, and her research team have published the results of a pilot study on the use of a body neutrality workbook intervention to improve physical activity and motivation in insufficiently active women. The paper has been published online ahead of print in the American Journal of Lifestyle Medicine, a Sage publication.

Nearly half of adult women in the United States do not meet recommended levels of moderate-to-vigorous physical activity (MVPA), despite well-established health benefits. Sociocultural pressures emphasizing thinness and appearance may promote controlled, appearance-based motivation for physical activity, a motivational orientation that has been associated with less sustained engagement.

This pilot study examined whether a 6-week, self-guided body neutrality workbook intervention was associated with changes in MVPA and psychological mediators of physical activity among insufficiently active adult women. Body neutrality shifts attention away from physical appearance and toward body functionality, self-care, and self-worth independent of body size. The workbook uses daily exercises, journaling, and reflection prompts to foster self-acceptance. Instead of forcing body positivity or loving one’s appearance, the guide teaches the user to view their body as a neutral vessel focused on function and respect.

Twenty participants who did not meet physical activity guidelines at baseline completed pre- and post-intervention assessments of MVPA, motivation, basic psychological needs, body image constructs, and physical intentions and planning. Results indicated a moderate increase in MVPA. Improvements were also observed in autonomy, competence, intrinsic and integrated motivation, body functionality appreciation, body compassion, and physical intentions and planning, alongside reductions in introjected regulation and appearance-based social comparison.

The findings suggest that a body neutrality approach may support more autonomous motivation for physical activity. Although limited by small sample size and lack of a control group, this study provides preliminary evidence that body neutrality-based interventions may represent a promising, scalable strategy to promote both psychological well-being and physical activity engagement among adult women. Research significance, intervention methods, data collection and analysis, and conclusions are detailed in the American Journal of Lifestyle Medicine paper.

This research was sponsored by Klein Buendel and led by Dr. Kayla Nuss, in collaboration with Ms. Anne Poirier from Shaping Perspective LLC. Shaping Perspectives is a women’s wellness education and coaching company that specializes in body image, body neutrality, intuitive eating, and sustainable health behavior change. Ms. Poirier is a Certified Intuitive Eating Counselor, Eating Disorder Specialist, and author. She has authored three best-selling books and has three more publishing this year, including the second, expanded edition of her seminal work, The Body Joyful.  

Perceived Costs and Rewards of Sun Protection among High School Students

Perceived Costs and Rewards of Sun Protection among High School Students

Adolescents frequently engage in behaviors that increase ultraviolet radiation (UVR) exposure, elevating their lifetime risk for skin cancer. Project Shine examined cross-sectional associations between high school students’ perceptions of the costs of UVR protection, the rewards of tanning, and their engagement in UVR-protective behaviors to identify opportunities for intervention.

New findings from this study have been published in Cancer Epidemiology. Biomarkers, and Prevention, a journal of the American Association for Cancer Research. The project was led by Dr. Yelena Wu from the Huntsman Cancer Institute at the University of Utah. Dr. David Buller from Klein Buendel was a member of the multi-institutional team.

Data were analyzed from 2,105 students (46% male; 77% White; and 33.4% rural) at baseline who enrolled in the Sun-safe Habits Intervention and Education cluster-randomized trial conducted in Utah high schools from 2021 to 2023. Students completed self-reports of skin cancer prevention knowledge, time spent outdoors, perceived costs of UVR protection, perceived rewards of tanning, and UVR-protective behaviors. Analyses included bivariate tests and multivariable regression, adjusted for demographics and knowledge.

Methods, analyses, and findings are described in detail in the Cancer Epidemiology, Biomarkers, and Prevention publication. In summary, students who perceived higher costs of UVR protection and greater rewards of tanning engaged in fewer UVR-protective behaviors. In an adjusted model, lower sun-safe behavior was independently predicted by lower knowledge of UVR safety, higher perceived protection cost, and greater tanning reward. Perceived costs of UVR protection and appearance-based rewards of tanning are key attributes of adolescent UVR exposure.

The authors suggest that school-based skin cancer prevention should incorporate appearance-focused and tailored strategies (such as UV photography or photoaging feedback) to promote sustainable sun safety behaviors. Addressing both cognitive and motivational barriers to UVR protection during adolescence could strengthen early prevention efforts and reduce future skin cancer burden.

This research was supported by a grant from the National Cancer Institute (CA244674; Dr. Yelena Wu, Principal Investigator). Co-authors include Omar Anwar, Marcelo Sleiman, Jr., Muriel Statman, and Dr. Kenneth Tercyak from the Lombardi Comprehensive Cancer Center at Georgetown University; Dr. Tammy Stump, Dr. Jakob Jensen, Dr. Douglas Grossman, Dr. Jincheng Shen, and Dr. Benjamin Haaland from the Huntsman Cancer Institute at the University of Utah; Dr. Jennifer Hay from Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center in New York; and Dr. David Buller from Klein Buendel. Support was also provided by Georgetown University, the University of Utah, and Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center.

Noncompliance with laws to prevent polysubstance misuse

Noncompliance with laws to prevent polysubstance misuse

The effectiveness of statutes to combat hazardous polysubstance use (for example, alcohol and cannabis together) has rarely been evaluated. A multi-institutional team led by Klein Buendel researchers assessed compliance with a state law prohibiting recreational cannabis sales to apparently intoxicated customers in one of the first states to legalize cannabis sales. The assessment has been published in Alcohol: Clinical and Experimental Research.

In January to June 2024, pseudo-patrons visited 189 recreational cannabis stores twice in two large metropolitan areas and attempted to purchase cannabis while displaying alcohol intoxication behaviors. Observers recorded whether sellers were willing to sell the product along with characteristics of the stores (busyness, cleanliness, and signage) and cannabis sellers (sex, race and ethnicity, and age). Neighborhood characteristics by U.S. census tract were obtained (income, race, and ethnicity; population density). Sex and race and ethnicity of the pseudo-patrons, and extent and type of intoxication cues, were recorded. Descriptive statistics and logistic regression were used to describe the sales rate and predictors of the sales rate.

Assessments were completed at 173 stores. Sellers were willing to sell cannabis to pseudo-intoxicated buyers at 255 of 346 visits (73.7%). Sellers refused buyers at both visits in 6.9% of stores but in 54.3% were willing to sell at both visits. Sellers refused cannabis sales at higher rates in stores with signs saying, “no sales to intoxicated customers” (34.3%), particularly when buyers displayed more obvious signs of intoxication (39.8%).

Low compliance with the state regulation possibly occurred because sellers were unaware of the law, perceived little deterrence by the law, or lacked the skills to recognize and refuse intoxicated customers. Noncompliance with the law on selling cannabis to apparently alcohol-intoxicated customers increases the risks of polysubstance impairment and harm.

This research is supported by a grant from the National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism (AA031591; Dr. W. Gill Woodall and Dr. David Buller, Multiple Principal Investigators). Additional collaborating authors include Dr. Robert Saltz from the Pacific Institute for Research and Evaluation; Dr. James Fell from Fell Consulting; Dr. Gary Cutter from the University of Alabama; and Lila Martinez, Amanda Brice, and Noah Chirico from Klein Buendel.

Development of an Online Cancer Prevention Intervention for Rural Emerging Adults

Development of an Online Cancer Prevention Intervention for Rural Emerging Adults

A multi-state research team from Arizona, Colorado, New Mexico, and Utah has published research on a rural health intervention in the Journal of Medical Internet Research. The study developed and pilot tested a theory-based intervention via the web to reduce six cancer risk factors among rural emerging adults through community-engaged research.

The rapid growth of user-generated web-based health information increases the complexity of cancer information seeking. One promising strategy for promoting high-quality cancer information consumption is through targeted interventions that are intentionally designed to reach individuals in the online spaces they occupy. However, there is a paucity of evidence-based information on the best strategies for designing and implementing web-based health behavior change interventions to improve individuals’ cancer-related knowledge and prevent cancer.

This mixed methods approach describes the development of an online cancer prevention intervention aimed at rural emerging adults aged 18-26 years in the United States and delivered in Facebook private groups. The intervention was guided by behavior change theory and co-created with young adults and Stakeholder Organization Advisory Boards to ensure relevance, accessibility, and appropriateness. The paper reported on three formative surveys, a pilot intervention, protocol development, and the community-engaged process for intervention development.

The authors developed 400 posts for a Facebook feed aimed at reducing six cancer risk behaviors (unhealthy diet, lack of physical activity, tobacco use, alcohol use, sun exposure, and human papillomavirus infection) with iterative input from the emerging adults and stakeholder advisory boards. Formative surveys with rural 297 emerging adults and a pilot study of the intervention with this 26 people from this population were conducted. In the pilot study, the intervention reached a sample of participants across several rural counties, with sustained engagement over a one-month period. Key modifications to the intervention content and design emerged from both advisory boards, the formative surveys, and the pilot intervention, focusing on using perceived reliable sources and direct links to source material.

The authors concluded that this web-based cancer prevention intervention is scalable and delivers engaging, evidence-informed health information to rural emerging adults. They offered key insights into the design and implementation of web-based cancer prevention interventions for emerging adults by describing the resources, timelines, and expertise needed to design and implement the intervention. Considerations for fully engaging young people and community stakeholder partners are presented, and how their involvement resulted in modifications that strengthened the intervention was discussed. Finally, the authors highlighted the importance of theory-based health-behavior messaging, digital messaging skillsets, and platform-tailored dissemination strategies for maximizing web-based intervention acceptability.

The research is supported by a grant from the National Cancer Institute (CA268037; Dr. David Buller and Dr. Andrew Sussman, Multiple Principal Investigators). Dr. Buller is the Director of Research at Klein Buendel. Dr. Sussman is from the University of New Mexico Comprehensive Cancer Center. Other collaborating investigators are from the University of Utah, the University of Arizona, the University of Colorado, and Colorado State University. The lead author of the Journal of Medical Internet Research paper is Dr. Echo Warner from the College of Nursing and the Huntsman Cancer Institute at the University of Utah.

Who Gives a Hoot about Heat?

Who Gives a Hoot about Heat?

Extreme heat is the leading cause of weather-related deaths. Prevention includes personal practices and emergency procedures. Behavioral interventions to improve prevention of heat-related illnesses are a priority.

Utilizing systematic review methodology, a comprehensive search strategy was deployed to identify studies reporting evaluations of behavioral heat-illness prevention interventions. Data sources included prominent bibliographic databases and relevant grey literature searches. Inclusion criteria indicated that studies that enrolled adult participants, assessed heat-related outcomes quantitatively, and were published in English from January 2000 to October 2023 be included. Data on study design, intervention features, and outcomes from the retained studies were extracted. A narrative synthesis was conducted, given the small number of studies and heterogeneous features.

Seventeen articles reporting on results from 13 studies were retained. Samples included outdoor workers, professional athletes, or community members (20,154 participants). Study quality was variable, with only two studies classified as good quality. Outcomes assessed were cognitive variables (such as knowledge, attitudes, and intentions), behaviors (such as water intake and dehydration), and clinical indicators (such as kidney function). Seven studies evaluated a health education intervention, two studies tested warning messages, and two studies focused on provision of personal protection equipment. Interventions improved self-reported heat-illness knowledge and prevention behaviors, and reduced deaths. Kidney function and health were improved in two studies. 

The published literature on behavioral heat-related illness prevention interventions was limited, despite frequent periods of high heat. The published evidence suggested that interventions can improve prevention knowledge and behavior and possibly reduce heat injury. Study designs need substantial improvement by including larger samples and randomized designs with comparison groups to avoid threats to internal and external validity in existing data. Policy efforts should be considered along with health education and provision of personal protection equipment to ensure populations are adequately protected.

This research was supported by a grant (U48DP006377) from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention to the Emory University Prevention Research Center (Dr. Alex Morshed from Emory University and Dr. David Buller from Klein Buendel, MPIs). Additional authors on this publication include Ms. Radhika Agarwal, Dr. Shenita Peterson, Dr. Cam Escoffery, and Ms. Kayla Anderson from Emory University; and Ms. Irene Adjei, Ms. Mary Buller, and Dr. Barbara Walkosz from Klein Buendel.

B-SMART App for DWI Offenders and Family Reduced Alcohol Use and Ignition Interlock Device Lockouts

B-SMART App for DWI Offenders and Family Reduced Alcohol Use and Ignition Interlock Device Lockouts

Driving while intoxicated (DWI) remains a preventable source of morbidity and mortality in the United States. Ignition interlock devices (IIDs) are used to prevent DWI offenders from driving while intoxicated during a mandated installation period and are effective during that time. Once IIDs are removed, DWI rates are like levels of offenders who had no IID.

Researchers at Klein Buendel and the University of New Mexico have published the results of a study that tested the efficacy of a new smartphone app (B-SMART) for DWI offenders with an IID and concerned family members, with the goal of reducing IID alcohol consumption and lockout events. The full paper with methods, analyses, and results has been published in the Journal of Studies on Alcohol and Drugs.

Four B-SMART app modules were developed: 1) Life with Interlock, 2) Supporting Changes in Drinking, 3) Doing Things Together, and 4) Effective Communication. Participants (pairs of DWI offenders and concerned family members) were randomly assigned to receive the B-SMART app (n=58) or referral to a state IID information page, considered usual and customary care (n=65), and followed for nine months. IID data (failed tests and lockout events) were obtained from IID providers as the primary outcome variables. Offender and CFM reports of alcohol consumption in the last 30 days prior to assessment were secondary measures.

IID data were collected on 62% (n=76) of participants. B-SMART participants had significantly fewer lockout events than usual and customary care participants. B-SMART offenders and their concerned family members reported significantly less likelihood of DWI offender drinking at the 9-month follow-up.

Results suggest the B-SMART app reduced DWI offender alcohol consumption and IID lockout events. These outcomes are important because fewer IID lockout events predict lower DWI recidivism.

This research was supported by a grant from the National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism (AA022850; Dr. W. Gill Woodall, Principal Investigator). Collaborators on this paper include Dr. Barbara McCrady and Dr. Vern Westerberg from the University of New Mexico; and Julia Berteletti, Lila Martinez, Marita Brooks, and Noah Chirico from Klein Buendel; and Thomas Starke from Impact DWI. The B-SMART app was developed by the Creative Team at Klein Buendel.

Mandatory Training Increases Drink Refusals to Intoxicated Patrons in California

Mandatory Training Increases Drink Refusals to Intoxicated Patrons in California

Klein Buendel scientists and staff are collaborators on a study that evaluated mandatory responsible beverage service training in California and its association with higher refusals of service to apparently intoxicated patrons in drinking establishments. The study, led by Dr. Robert Saltz at the Pacific Institute for Research and Evaluation, has been published in the Journal of Studies on Alcohol and Drugs.

The California Responsible Beverage Service (RBS) Training Act mandated training for all alcohol servers by 2023, giving this multi-institutional research team a rare opportunity to see how a statewide initiative might influence server behavior.

In 2022, 300 licensed on-premises establishments were sampled in nine counties in and around the San Francisco Bay Area. From July 2022 to January 2023, pseudo-patron and observer teams visited each establishment, and pseudo-patrons attempted to buy alcohol while displaying obvious signs of intoxication. The outcome of each purchase attempt and characteristics of establishments, servers, and pseudo-patrons, and month, day, and time, were recorded. In 2024, the same premises were visited as a follow up.

At baseline, 19.6% of the outlets refused service to the pseudo-patron. At follow up, the refusal rate increased significantly to 39.2% in a regression model controlling for establishment, server, and pseudo-patron characteristics. A typology of establishments (such as sports bar, casual restaurant, fine dining restaurant) did not show any association with refusal rate except that fine dining places refused more often than other types of establishments. Observers’ ratings of how obvious the pseudo-patron’s apparent intoxication was strongly associated with refusals.

The researchers conclude that there was substantial improvement in alcohol over-service refusals two years after the California mandatory RBS training law went into effect.

This research was funded by a grant to PIRE from the National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism (AA028772; Dr. Robert Saltz, Principal Investigator).  Co-authors include Dr. Mallie Paschall and Dr. Sharon O’Hara from PIRE; and Dr. W. Gill Woodall, Dr. David Buller, and Ms. Lila Martinez from Klein Buendel.  

Feasibility of the STAC-T Bullying Bystander App

Feasibility of the STAC-T Bullying Bystander App

STAC-T, which included a 40-minute training and a 15-minute booster session, was completed by 249 middle school students recruited from six middle schools in rural, low-income communities in the United States. Students completed a post-training survey assessing program acceptability and relevance, whether they witnessed bullying post-training, and the use of the STAC strategies to intervene in bullying situations. Descriptive statistics were used to assess acceptability, relevance, and the use of STAC strategies. Linear regression analysis was used to assess the relationship of program acceptability and relevance to STAC strategy use.

Most students reported the program was acceptable (82.1 to 90.0%) and relevant (78.6 to 83.0%) for students at their school; 88.8% (111) of the 50.2% (125) of students who witnessed bullying post-training also reported the use of at least one STAC strategy to intervene when witnessing bullying. Program relevance was a significant predictor of post-training use of STAC strategies. In contrast, program acceptability was not a significant predictor of post-training STAC strategy use.

This study provides support for the acceptability and relevance of STAC-T, as well as the effectiveness in promoting the use of the STAC strategies to intervene in bullying situations. Further, program relevance was related to STAC strategy use, highlighting the importance of assessing program relevance for specific student populations.  

The multi-institutional team was led by Dr. Aida Midgett from Boise State University. Collaborators included Dr. Diana Doumas, Taylor Perron, and Jennalyn Shelton from Boise State University; Dr. Robin Hausheer from the University of Vermont; Dr. Amanda Winburn from the University of Mississippi; and Brandon Herbeck and Mary Buller from Klein Buendel. The research was supported by a grant to Klein Buendel from the National Institute on Minority Health and Health Disparities (R42MD014943; Dr. Aida Midgett, Principal Investigator).

Helps and hindrances to passing state indoor tanning laws

Helps and hindrances to passing state indoor tanning laws

Indoor tanning causes skin cancers, including potentially deadly melanoma. Indoor tanning often starts during youth, a critical time for deleterious skin damage. About half of U.S. states have enacted laws banning indoor tanning for minors under the age of 18. A multi-institutional team of researchers including Dr. David Buller and Julia Berteletti from Klein Buendel has published a paper in Translational Behavioral Medicine that reports qualitative findings from interviews with key informants involved in indoor tanning legislative efforts to identify/describe factors influencing law enactment, based on the Multiple Streams Framework (1).

Guided by expert advisors and using snowball-sampling, 64 key informants from 16 states with most recently enacted indoor tanning laws regulating minor access and states without restrictions were contacted. In virtual interviews, key informants shared their unique “story” of indoor tanning bill efforts, enactment, implementation, impact, and potential future directions, which were transcribed and qualitatively coded by trained staff.

Although key informant roles (legislators, advocates, clinicians, and melanoma survivors) and legislative processes vary by state, similar facilitators and barriers to indoor tanning bill passage were identified: personal stories, advocacy, opposition, preparation, legislator education, economic/ enforcement issues, bill stringency, political values/partisanship, and legislative process. Other factors influencing bill enaction included failed U.S. Food and Drug Administration attempts toward federally banning minor indoor tanning and competing priorities.

Despite evidence of laws’ impact on minors’ indoor tanning, policy enaction is challenging and slow. Understanding key facilitators and barriers may help advocates to advance legislation efforts. Advocating for stringent laws necessitates consideration of potential downstream effects. For example, even with policy enactment, key informants believed enforcement and compliance were likely insufficient and variable, with minors continuing to indoor tan, putting them at risk for potentially deadly skin cancer.

This research was supported by a grant to Rutgers University from the National Cancer Institute (CA244370; Dr. Carolyn Heckman and Dr. David Buller, Multiple Principal Investigators). Authors include Dr. Carolyn Heckman, Ms. Anna Mitarotondo, Mr. Kevin Schroth, and Dr. Shawna Hudson from Rutgers University; Dr. Jerod Stapleton from the University of Kentucky; Dr. Robert Dellavalle from the University of Minnesota; Dr. Sophie Balk from the Albert Einstein College of Medicine; and Dr. David Buller and Ms. Julia Berteletti from Klein Buendel.

References

  1. Kingdon JW. Agendas, Alternatives, and Public Policies. Longman, 2003.